|
Read our recent newsletter for more information and a discussion about the recent media reports concerning HRT.
What is meant by hormonal replacement therapy (HRT)? It is the artificial replacement of the hormone estrogen . This replacement can be taken in different forms. It can be taken orally (tablets). It is also possible to administer it through the skin (via patches that stick to the skin or ointments applied to the skin). It can also be injected or implanted underneath the skin.
The abbreviation HRT is used on this page and refers to hormonal replacement therapy.
Should a post menopausal woman use HRT? This is presently a controversial subject. Each individual should decide for herself, but she should be able to make an informed decision. We will discuss the advantages and disadvantages and also refer you to other sites in order to help you to make a decision.
You will see that there are risks both ways. There are certain risks when not taking HRT and other risks when taking hormonal replacement.
Advantages of HRT
1 Preventing Osteoporosis
Oestrogen slows down the reabsorption of bone and this prevent osteoporosis. It might also help to improve bone mass and density in women that are already at risk for having fractures. Osteoporosis is discussed in more detail in on this page.
2 Preventing Ischemic Heart Disease
Ischemic heart disease and coronary artery thrombosis is rare in pre menopausal (before the menopause) women. Following the menopause there is a sharp increase in the incidence of these deceases . There is strong evidence that the use of HRT helps to keep the incidence of ischemic heart diseases low at the pre menopausal level. It also seems that HRT must be started early, at the onset of the menopause , to be effective. It is to late and will probably have no beneficial effect if the coronary arteries are already effected and sick. Than there is a even an increased risk of thrombosis. The coronary arteries are the arteries that supply blood to the heart muscle.
About four times more women die from heart attacks after the menopause than from breast cancer. It is still to early to say if HRT will decreased the incidence of heart attacks. At this stage ( early 2002) it appears that if a women with a healthy heart at menopause start using HRT it will reduce her risk of ischemic heart disease. If however her heart is already effected or if she starts HRT after a heart attack it will not reduce her risk of further heart attacks.
This is presently a highly controversial subject. Many of the latest research cast doubt on the effectiveness of HRT in preventing heart attacks and strokes. Some criticism against studies showing an increase in heart attacks and strokes, is that there is doubt about the age at which the HRT commence. Was there already blood vessel damage when HRT was started?
Please refer to our August 2002 Newsletter and get the latest information.
We know if the experts are in doubt and not in complete agreement , how unsure must a lay person feel. Research is continuing and we hope to be able to have a clear answer in the near future.
3 Delaying the Onset of Alzheimer's Disease
There is more and more evidence indicating that HRT delay or postpone the onset of Alzheimer's disease. This is also not proven beyond doubt and more research are required.
4 Possible decrease in the Risk of Developing Colon Cancer
There is more and more evidence indicating that HRT delay or postpone the onset of Alzheimer's disease. This is also not proven beyond doubt and more research are required.
5 Relief of the menopausal and post menopausal symptoms
Hot flushes, dryness of the vagina, painful sexual intercourse, emotional disturbances ( difficulty controlling emotions), insomnia and dry skin are some of the common symptoms. HRT effectively reliefs all these symptoms.
Disadvantages of HRT
1 Effects on the Breasts
HRT and its effects on the breasts are presently a widely debated and discussed controversial topic. The main issue is DOES HRT USAGE INCREASES THE RISK OF BREAST CANCER?
If all the presently available knowledge and research data are analyzed we think that the following discussion accurately reflects and summarizes our present situation:
A. HRT probably does not change a normal cell into a cancer cell.
B. HRT will stimulate cancer cells that are already present to grow quicker. It accelerates breast cancer growth. Many researchers believe cancer is a slow disease at its onset and that it may take up to eight years for a cancerous breast lump to become palpable. WHEN THE LUMP IS DISCOVERED THE ABNORMALITY IS PROBABLY PRESENT FOR SEVERAL YEARS.
C This stimulating effect on cancer cells could create an impression that the incidence of breast cancer is slightly increased in women on HRT.
D. Women on HRT usually go for annual checkups and mammography. Cancer are therefore diagnosed early and this can also create an impression of a higher incidence of cancer.
E. Breast cancer is usually diagnosed earlier in on women on HRT than in women not taking any hormonal supplements.
F. The prognosis of women developing breast cancer while taking HRT is better than those who are develop it without taking HRT.
The points mentioned above are just impressions and not absolute facts. Thus is a controversial issue. Controlled research into the matter is complicated because the people most likely to use HRT are also the ones more likely to go for regular check ups and are most likely more health conscience. To get proper answers in any research project you need control groups with life styles as near as possible to the group that are being tested. The women on HRT and the control group not using HRT must be properly matched to get a reliable answer.
Another complicating factor is the fact that the risk of breast cancer increases with age. The age of onset of menopause might also play role ( the effects of the normal production of estrogen during the fertile life). The previous use of oral contraceptives is another factor to take into account. There are also other substances with estrogenic effects present in nature ( in plants). An example is soy sauce which have an estrogenic effect tissue. The intake of these substances might also influence the development of breast cancer. ( It is believed that some of them do not have estrogenic effects on the breasts and might have a protective effect against breast cancer)( see SERMS a bit later.)
The present controversies are probably due to (at least in part) to the factors discussed above. On fact is however clear from our present knowledge and that is if HRT usage increases the risk of breast cancer, than it is only a small increase in the risk. The risk is very small during the first ten years of HRT usage.
2 Effects on Blood Clotting
HRT usage increase the risk of intravascular coagulation, the formation of blood clots in the veins , especially the veins of the lower limbs ( legs) There is also an increase risk of strokes ( clots in the brains blood vessels. This risk is increased in smokers, persons with a history of previous blood clots and in people who are physically less active.(physical activity keeps blood circulating and helps to prevent blood from clotting in the blood vessels. Women taking HRT should always inform their surgeons and anesthetist about it before undergoing operations.
In a healthy non smoking women with a normal or low blood pressure it is doubtful of the risk is of any significance.
|